My Kind of Country

Country music from a fan's point of view since 2008

Album Review – Martina McBride – ‘The Way That I Am’

220px-Martina_McBride_-_The_Way_That_I_AmFollowing the commercial disappointment of The Time Has Come, RCA Records and producer Paul Worley led Martina McBride in a slightly slicker direction for her sophomore album The Way That I Am, released in the fall of 1993. With the neo-traditional movement in a decline, the record echoed the sounds of the time, increasing the prominence of drums and electric guitars without sacrificing the distinction of pedal steel heard throughout.

Gretchen Peters’ amped “My Baby Loves Me” was chosen as the lead single, and became McBride’s first top five hit. She followed with the equally upbeat and charming “Life #9,” which peaked at #6. Both are excellent and equally showcase McBride’s powerful voice in a contemporary enough setting to work within the confines of country radio at the time.

But just as she was taking off, McBride took a risk with Peters’ spousal abuse anthem “Independence Day,” which peaked at #12. The story of a girl orphaned when her sadistic father killed his wife and himself by setting their house on fire, was too controversial in a world dominated by the daily headlines of O.J. Simpson’s murder trial. But nonetheless, McBride’s powerful performance and an equally memorable music video elevated the track into her signature tune, and to this day its one of her most popular recurrent songs heard on country radio.

RCA released two other singles from the project, the mid-tempo but rather fluffy “Heart Trouble” (which peaked at #21) and the decidedly slow ballad “Where I Used To Have A Heart” (which peaked at #49). Neither is particularly memorable, nor strong enough to score big at radio.

McBride herself stated in the liner notes of her Greatest Hits album that the label should’ve gone with Bobby Braddock’s masterful “Strangers” in the wake of “Independence Day,” a fact I wholeheartedly agree with. My personal favorite of all her recordings, “Strangers” takes a powerful full-circle look at a couple’s courtship, marriage, and divorce flanked by them beginning and ending as strangers. It’s easily the strongest non-“issue” relationship song McBride has ever tackled, and the most well written power ballad of her career.

Pam Tillis and Bill Lloyd co-wrote the intriguing “Goin’ To Work,” a feminist anthem celebrating strong women who are proud to be in the workforce. I love the track, although it does beat the concept half to death by repeating the “going to work/I’m good at my work/thank god for my work” refrain into the ground. But McBride sings it well and I quite enjoy the melody.

She does her best with Gary Harrison and Tim Mensy’s “That Wasn’t Me,” a popish piano ballad, but the track lacks anything to elevate it beyond its simple yet elegant confines. Far better is the stunning “She Ain’t Seen Nothing Yet,” a neo-traditional ballad concerning a wife in denial about her husband’s affair. She falters, though, on the gimmicky “Ashes,” a drives-home-its-point-too-hard relationship song comparing a couple’s love affair to fireplace embers.

Overall, The Way That I Am is a very strong collection of songs tackling somewhat surprisingly heavy themes for an artist looking to gain traction at radio and retail. I’ll never understand what RCA was thinking with the latter two singles – I would’ve released “Strangers” and “Goin’ To Work” instead – but she thankfully survived it. Copies are available very cheaply and it’s well worth adding to any music collection.

Grade: A-

12 responses to “Album Review – Martina McBride – ‘The Way That I Am’

  1. Tom January 7, 2013 at 12:34 pm

    The father doesn’t burn down the house, the mother does in revenge/defiance. That’s why it’s called Independence Day.

  2. Occasional Hope January 7, 2013 at 1:13 pm

    Strangers is my favourite track here.

  3. Michael A. January 7, 2013 at 1:24 pm

    This album, Reba’s Read My Mind and Tanya Tucker’s Soon were the first country CDs I ever purchased in the Spring of 1994. Nice review.

  4. Ben Foster January 7, 2013 at 2:46 pm

    This is a very good album, with “My Baby Loves Me” and “Independence Day” being among my favorite McBride recordings. I agree with you on “Heart Trouble” though – that one was pretty forgettable. This review makes me think it’s about time I revisited this album.

  5. Jordan Stacey January 7, 2013 at 3:48 pm

    “Strangers” is probably one of the best songs she’s ever recorded and I’m more than a little shocked it had never been chosen as a single. I like “Heart Trouble” well enough but there was far better single material, and “Where I Used To Have A Heart” is such a bore that I’d have switched that one out for “Strangers”. “She Ain’t Seen Nothing Yet” would’ve also sufficed. I’m with Razor X though in thinking that “Goin’ To Work” shouldn’t have been a single, I don’t hate it but it was never my favorite track here. “Independence Day” will forever be the best single she released and it’s amazing to think that it and “Strangers” appeared on the same album. So early in her career and she already had 3 great songs.

  6. J.R. Journey January 7, 2013 at 3:59 pm

    I agree with everybody about “Strangers”. Not only is it a great, great song, it was one of the first instances of Martina’s rattle-the-rafters style of singing a ballad. I think this album had several great songs on it – “Strangers”, “Independence Day”, – but its still kinda spotty. She really came into her own with the next two albums IMO.

  7. Jonathan Pappalardo January 8, 2013 at 1:21 pm

    Thanks, everyone! Glad I’m not the only one unclear about the exact circumstances surrounding “Independence Day.”

    I think we all can agree “Strangers” is pretty awesome, and I’m glad Martina thought to include it on her GH album, because otherwise I likely wouldn’t have discovered it. When I originally looked at her GH tracklist, I thought it was one of the newly recorded tracks. Yah. Guess I wasn’t keen on album cuts when I was younger.

  8. Pingback: Sammy Johns Passes Away; Luke Bryan to Co-host ACM Awards with Blake Shelton; Chris Knight Premieres New Video - Engine 145

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: