My Kind of Country

Country music from a fan's point of view since 2008

Album Review: LeAnn Rimes – ‘Lady & Gentlemen’

When LeAnn Rimes made her impressive debut aged just 13, she did so with a vintage song originally written for Patsy Cline. Her career subsequently veered popwards, with LeAnn often not seeming to be certain of her own musical identity. Most recently she has been producing solid pop-country, but her chart career has been overshadowed by a tangled personal life. So I was intrigued to hear that she might be returning to country classics – at least, until I heard the first single. I hated LeAnn’s manically speeded up and overwrought version of John Anderson’s hit ‘Swingin’, and was left gloomy about the album’s likely direction, despite Vince Gill being named as the producer. (He is in fact joined in that task on the bulk of the record by Justin Niebank, Darrell Brown (LeAnn’s regular co-writer) and John Hobbs, with Gill, Brown and Leann responsible for the arrangements). Happily, the end result is much better than I feared it might be, with the awful, misconceived assault on ‘Swingin’ the only track I really dislike.

There are a couple of other tracks which don’t quite work for me: a horn-accompanied and passionately sung ‘16 Tons’ sounds great if you don’t listen to the words, but is completely unconvincing as a working man’s anthem. Her reworking of producer Vince’s great ‘When I Call Your Name’ as a jazz-soul song wanders too far from the original melody and emotion for me, but is very accomplished in its way and will appeal to some.

Freddy Fender’s Tex-Mex ‘Wasted Days And Wasted Nights’ in contrast has a lovely retro, slightly loungy feel, with lovely phrasing and a small section sung in Spanish. I also enjoyed a new, mature version of her own first hit ‘Blue’, featuring Vince Gill’s side band the Time Jumpers. I enjoyed LeAnn’s enthusiastic take on Waylon’s ‘The Only Daddy That’ll Walk The Line’, given a gender rewrite as ‘The Only Mama That’ll Walk The Line’. The Waylon/Willie hit ‘A Good Hearted Woman’ is speeded up a bit too much, but still quite enjoyable, expressed in the first person. John Conlee’s ‘Rose Colored Glasses’ is well sung but lacks the intensity of emotion of the original, although the production is more tasteful.

There are three outstanding tracks. While she cannot quite match George Jones on the hallowed ground of ‘He Stopped Loving her Today’, she gives a beautifully understated reading which works extremely well, with Vince adding harmony on the chorus. This is the one which best reveals LeAnn’s growth as an interpreter. A measured, emotional version of Haggard’s depiction of being trapped in an unhappy marriage where ‘I Can’t Be Myself’ is superb. LeAnn’s seductive and emotional plea to ‘Help Me Make It Through the Night’ is almost as good.

Haggard’s ‘The Bottle Let Me Down’ (one of three afterthoughts produced by LeAnn with Darrell Brown) was a good addition to the tracklist. On first hearing I thought it paled in comparison to both the original and Emmylou Harris’s defiant cover, but over repeated listens, I have grown to appreciate the sense of defeat and regret in LeAnn’s version.

The other two are brand new songs, which have both been tried, and failed, as radio singles. They are out of place here, sounding much more contemporary, and they contradict the original conceit of the album, the idea that these were all “men’s songs” given a new interpretation by LeAnn. The aggressive Miranda Lambert style gender war of ‘Crazy Women’, written by Brandy Clark, Shane McAnally and Jessie Jo Dillon suffers from a cluttered modern production and rather limited melody, while the gentler but still contemporary ‘Give’, written by Jimmy Yeary and Connie Harrington has a well meaning message and is pleasant sounding but a little dull.

Interestingly, this is one of very few modern albums to get a vinyl release alongside CD and digital availability. Sales so far are reportedly low, which is a shame, because this is LeAnn’s best work for some time, and for me it fulfils for the first time the potential she had as a phenomenal teenager. Her vocals are great, and her sometimes muddy diction has also improved.

Grade: A-

8 responses to “Album Review: LeAnn Rimes – ‘Lady & Gentlemen’

  1. Paul W Dennis October 13, 2011 at 12:14 pm

    Other than “Swingin ” and the two new songs, I really liked this album, even “16 Tons” which is a little odd but otherwise enjoyable. I really liked “The Bottle Let Me Down” – she’s not Merle but I like her version better that I did Emmylou’s cover.

    And you are correct – her diction seems to be improving

  2. Danny Barker October 13, 2011 at 1:55 pm

    Change is good for some because there are a lot more music lovers out there who like all kinds music. Some people cross over is good ,some have seem realy forgot how they got to where are to day..Iam just saying.

  3. luckyoldsun October 13, 2011 at 5:30 pm

    “16 Tons”?? Really.

    Leann seems to be harking back to the era of Leadbelly and Carter Family and Woody Guthrie, when men could sing songs in the personas of women and women could sing songs in the personas of men and nobody thought anything of it. I don’t think the world is reay to go back in that direction.

  4. Ben Foster October 13, 2011 at 10:08 pm

    A- is a good grade for this album. It’s not perfect, but it’s overall a very strong effort.

    I have to say I’ve always adored her version of “Swingin’.” I don’t think it sounds awful; I think it sounds really cool and fun. John Anderson’s original is enjoyable, but it also sounds very dated. Part of the reason LeAnn’s version works for me is that it offers a version that sounds wholly modern and very inventive.

    I love the new version of “Blue,” particularly for its more mature sound, as well as the way it builds on the traditional elements of the original. Leeann mentioned over on CU that it sounds like something from Patty Loveless’s Sleepless Nights album, and I agree. “He Stopped Loving Her Today” is one of my favorite tracks. She could never top the Jones original, but to me it sounds like she knows that, and she’s not intending to. Nothing about the record sounds like she’s trying too hard. It sounds very natural, sincere, unaffected, and respectful of the original. Plus Vince Gill’s harmony vocal is just chill-inducing. I also enjoy her version of “The Bottle Let Me Down” – I think it puts a more gloomy spin on the song, and it works very well. I love “16 Tons” also, though now I can see why some might see the arrangement as an awkward fit, though I personally like it. “When I Call Your Name” is bound to be polarizing, and while it definitely doesn’t match Vince’s original, it’s really grown on me. I think it’s a very creative-sounding reinterpretation.

    I think the two original songs are good, but I agree that don’t fit in well with the rest of the album. I like the simple message of “Give,” but the lyric could benefit from scratching below the surface a bit. I like “Crazy Women” a bit more. It’s a very fun, clever, snarky little tune. I don’t really hear clutter in the production at all.

  5. luckyoldsun October 13, 2011 at 11:55 pm

    I suppose one reason this album went straight to the remainder bin is that it seems every woman veteran country singer of note has put out a classic covers album in the last few years–Patty, Martina, Tanya, Reba, Lorrie, Rosanne–it’s hard to keep track. Some of them are very good, but some are just me-too. This one seemed questionable to start with, but the dopey, god-awful first single, “Swingin’, really killed it.

    • Occasional Hope October 16, 2011 at 6:06 am

      I agree that the choice of Swinging for the first single was a major error, because the album as a whole is infinitely better.

  6. Penny Phillips December 22, 2011 at 9:11 pm

    Leann’s ‘Lady and Gentlemen’ is a work of art so very enjoyabl

  7. Pingback: Occasional Hope’s Top 10 Albums of 2011 « My Kind Of Country

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: