My Kind of Country

Country music from a fan's point of view since 2008

Album Review: Dolly Parton – ‘My Blue Ridge Mountain Boy’

Released in September 1969, My Blue Ridge Mountain Boy was Dolly’s third solo effort for RCA and her fourth solo album overall. At this stage of her career, she was still struggling to find her commercial breakthrough, having cracked the Top 20 as a solo artist only once, with the previous year’s “Just Because I’m A Woman.” Whereas her previous two albums had produced only one single each, My Blue Ridge Mountain Boy produced three, which suggests that RCA had some faith that they were on the right track. Indeed, it is a more consistent album than its somewhat uneven predecessors, and it charted higher, peaking at #6 on the Billboard country albums chart. However, none of the singles performed well on the charts, most likely due to their depressing and controversial — by 1969 standards — subject matter. Make no mistake, this album is no happy affair. The themes explored range from poverty, infidelity, and illegitimate birth to revenge, murder, suicide and prostitution.

In the first single, “Daddy”, Dolly is a young woman urging her father not to abandon her mother in favor of a woman who is younger than his daughter. One of her weaker efforts up to this point, it was an odd choice for lead single and it failed to gain much traction at radio, though it did manage to crack the Top 40 — the only single from the album to do so.

The second single was a cover of Mac Davis’ controversial “In The Ghetto”, which had been a recent hit for Elvis Presley. It tells the tale of the vicious cycle of crime and poverty in the inner city — a problem which has only worsened over the succeeding four decades. Likely considered too topical for country radio, it died at #50, despite an excellent performance which drew praise from Elvis himself. Equally controversial was the next single, the album’s title track, which tells the story of a young woman who leaves her rural home and the boy she loves for the bright lights of the city, only to find more than she bargained for and ultimately resorting to prostitution to survive. It performed slightly better than “In The Ghetto”, climbing to #45. Despite its commercial failure, it is relatively well known today thanks to its inclusion on a number of “best of” compilations over the years.

In addition to “Daddy” and the title tack, Dolly wrote three more of the album’s twelve tracks. In “Til Death Do Us Part”, the narrator commits suicide upon learning that her husband is leaving her for another woman. “Evening Shade” tells the story of an orphans home, in which the inhabitants seek their revenge by burning the place down while the cruel headmistress is sleeping inside. “Gypsy, Joe and Me” seems like a more lighthearted affair in the beginning, telling the story of a couple of free spirits and their dog. However, both the dog and the narrator’s partner meet with tragic ends, which ultimately leads the narrator to take her own life.

The fallen woman is a recurring theme throughout Parton’s early work, so it was somewhat surprising to learn that “Home For Pete’s Sake” is one of the tunes on the album which she did not write. On the other hand, it’s a little less surprising when one takes into account that this one actually has a happy ending. Unlike Dolly’s later composition “Down From Dover”, which would appear on the following year’s album, the protagonist in Rudy Preston’s “Home For Pete’s Sake” is welcomed home by her family and ex-boyfriend when she falls pregnant after moving to the big city.

Rounding out the set are covers of Joe South’s “Games People Play”, Jean Shepherd’s “We Had All The Good Things Going”, which had been a hit for Jean Shepherd, and Porter Wagoner’s “Big Wind”. While none of these can be said to be happy songs, they range from mid- to up-tempo and thus server to lighten the mood and save the album from becoming a total case of unabated misery.

The album’s cover art shows the cabin in Tennessee where Dolly grew up, and the gentleman posing as The Blue Ridge Mountain Boy is none other than Dolly’s husband, the reclusive Carl Dean. Bob Ferguson was credited as producer, but in reality, like all of Parton’s work from this era, My Blue Ridge Mountain Boy was produced by her mentor Porter Wagoner. At the time, RCA would only allow employees of the label to produce, so Ferguson got the credit even though he was rarely present in the studio when Parton and Wagoner were recording.

Bleak and somber though the subject matter may be, My Blue Ridge Mountain Boy is first rate from beginning to end and is worthy of a remastering and re-release. Unfortunately, it has never been released on CD, though used vinyl copies can be purchased. In addition, most the album’s tracks can be found on various hits compilations, and many of them can be individually downloaded.

Grade: A

7 responses to “Album Review: Dolly Parton – ‘My Blue Ridge Mountain Boy’

  1. Ken Johnson July 6, 2011 at 9:10 pm

    No question that the choice of songs selected for Dolly’s early single releases was not exactly in synch with much of the late 1960’s mainstream country music audience. However, I would argue that the sound of Dolly’s unusual voice was the primary problem with her initial acceptance. Many country radio programmers as well as country fans were not exactly captivated by Dolly’s rather odd vocal delivery. Her “little girl” voice was a big change for country fans who were used to hearing Kitty Wells, Jean Shepard , Loretta Lynn, Tammy Wynette or the amazingly gifted Connie Smith. Duet recordings with core country icon Porter Wagoner and the weekly exposure on his TV Show paved the way to make Dolly become a star in her own right as fans became comfortable and familiar with her distinctive vocals.

    Just one correction to your excellent analysis of this album. “We Had All The Good Things Going” was a #20 hit for Jan Howard in late 1969.

    Despite the rather depressing tone of the songs in this album it sure beats the pop fluff that Dolly cranked out in the late 1970’s & ‘80’s by a country mile.

  2. Kevin July 12, 2011 at 10:37 am

    This, along with In The Good Old Days and Touch Your Woman, is on the top of my Dolly Parton reissue wish list.

    We’ve already gotten “A Real Live Dolly” and “The Fairest of Them All”, so there’s hope yet. It seems like the international market is taking the lead to make sure her albums become available, while RCA in America reissues Coat of Many Colors, Jolene, and 9 to 5 over and over again!

    • Razor X July 12, 2011 at 7:47 pm

      I don’t know why they don’t re-release this one. Most of the tracks have already appeared on other compilation CDs, so they wouldn’t have to go back and re-master the whole thing. There wouldn’t be much expense associated with releasing it.

  3. Rexroth'sDaughter February 13, 2018 at 1:18 pm

    Great review of a great album. One small correction: “We Had All of the Good Things Going” was actually a hit for Jan Howard, not Jean Shepherd.

  4. Jack February 18, 2018 at 3:34 pm

    Dadгdy you didn?t say what the very best factor about God is.
    Its a must to play too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: