My Kind of Country

Country music from a fan's point of view since 2008

Album Review: ‘She Thinks I Still Care: The George Jones Collection’

George Jones’ landmark 1960 recording “The Window Up Above” was the apex of his years with Mercury Records. It marked his transition from a singer of honky tonk barn burners to a Nashville Sound ballad crooner. By 1962, he made the switch to United Artists Records and continued to perfect his craft. This collection, released in 1997 by Razor & Tie, focuses on his tenure with United Artists, which lasted from 1962 until 1964. Though his stint with the label was a short one, it yielded 151 recordings, including a handful of true classics that are the best of his career prior to his period with Epic Records (1971 to 1991). Twenty-two of those 151 recordings were released as singles, and twenty-one of them are represented here; the sole omission is 1963’s non-charting “Ain’t It Funny What A Fool Will Do.”

United Artists at the time was a fledgling label that had been started primarily to release soundtrack albums of UA films. It later branched out into jazz, and when Mercury executive Art Talmadge was recruited to start a country division, Pappy Dailey and George Jones joined him. They hit paydirt straight out of the box with “She Thinks I Still Care”, his first release for the label. It was his third #1 hit and the biggest record of his career to date. Originally intended as a pop ballad, it was pitched to Jones by former Sun Records producer Jack Clement, who altered the melody to make it sound more country. It has been covered many times by artists such as Elvis Presley, Anne Murray, and Patty Loveless.

George’s next few releases — all released in 1962– didn’t fare quite as well. “Sometimes You Just Can’t Win” reached #17, “Open Pit Mine” peaked at #13, and “You’re Still On My Mind” petered out at #28. His fortunes turned around by year-end, with “A Girl I Used To Know”, a #3 hit written by Jack Clement that is better known in its slightly re-tooled duet version. As “Just Someone I Used To Know”, it has been recorded many, many times, most notably by Porter Wagoner and Dolly Parton in 1969. Jones closed out 1962 with “The Big Fool Of The Year”, which peaked at #13. He greeted 1963 with the somewhat similar sounding “Not What I Had In Mind”, a somewhat forgotten and definitely underrated number that reached #7 on the charts.

In 1963, Jones was paired with another Pappy Dailey client, Melba Montgomery, for a series of successful duets, seven of which are represented here. The best known is “We Must Have Been Out Of Our Minds”, which Melba wrote, but all of the Montgomery duets included in this collection are worthwhile. Melba’s raw bluegrass harmonies matched Jones more polished vocal style quite nicely on tunes such as “She’s My Mother”, “Let’s Invite Them Over”, “Blue Moon of Kentucky” and “What’s In Our Hearts.” All of the Jones-Montgomery duets were recorded live in the studio with no overdubs, and George reportedly considers them to be the best duets of his career, trumping even his better-known later work with Tammy Wynette.

After “She Thinks I Still Care”, the best known record from Jones’ UA period is “The Race Is On”, an upbeat number that reached #3 and has also been covered many times by artists such as The Grateful Dead and pop singer Jack Jones (no relation). In 1989 the song revived the flagging career of Sawyer Brown.

In addition to the aforementioned big hits, this two-disc collection is rounded out by some religious songs and a few covers of other artists’ songs, most notably “Faded Love”, which was included on Jones’ 1962 Bob Wills tribute album.

Only a small handful of Jones’ recordings from the United Artists era are considered essential, but it’s my favorite phase of his career from the pre-Epic years. This particular collection is currently out of print. Used copies are available from third-party sellers on Amazon, but they are quite expensive. Bear Family Records released the entire UA catalog in a five-disc box set called She Thinks I Still Care: The Complete United Artists Recordings: 1962-1964, but it too is quite expensive and only of interest to diehard fans. More economical is a single-disc, ten track 2003 collection released by Capitol, also called She Thinks I Still Care. Like the Razor & Tie collection, this one is also out of print, but cheap used copies are available. The song selection on the Capitol disc is meager and there some glaring omissions such as “The Race Is On” and “A Girl I Used To Know.” It’s difficult to find a decent compilation of the United Artists years without breaking the budget, but any money used to purchase any of these recordings is money well spent.

Grade: A

5 responses to “Album Review: ‘She Thinks I Still Care: The George Jones Collection’

  1. Paul W Dennis July 9, 2010 at 9:23 am

    There are those who consider that the artist peak of George’s career coincided with his tenure at United Artist . I am among those.

    Even some of the lesser hits such as “You’re Still On My Mind” and “Sometimes You Just Can’t Win” are true classics (it boggles the mind that both of these records weren’t top five chart records). George was in very good voice throughout the period and had acces to the best material

    Many of the United Artist albums were issued on individual CDs on labels such as Koch and Razor & Tie. Though now out of print, titles like THE RACE IS ON, GEORGE JONES SINGS LIKE THE DICKENS, SINGS BOB WILLS, MY FAVORITE HANK WILLIAMS can sometimes be found in used CD shops or through online vendors

  2. Ken Johnson July 10, 2010 at 1:05 pm

    The Razor & Tie 2-CD set serves as an excellent overview of George Jones’ United Artist years. The overall high quality of George’s recordings during his brief three year stint with this label cannot be overstated. By 1962 he had fully developed his own unique style and chose material that gave him the perfect showcase for his expressive voice. As mentioned previously Pappy Daily served as producer in name only so that George maintained a great deal of control and freedom at these sessions to choose and record songs in a manner most comfortable to him. The development of high quality multi-track recording equipment and the refinement of Nashville studio recording techniques by 1962 contributed to the clarity and brightness of these sessions.

    The Razor & Tie CD contains the hit versions of George’s United Artists singles with one exception. The single hit version of “Not What I Had In Mind” (UA-528) was never released on a United Artists LP. It was recorded at the same September 13, 1962 session that produced “I Saw Me,” which served as the “B” side of that single. Inexplicably an earlier version of “Not What I Had In Mind” recorded on June 11, 1962 was used for all album and CD releases of that song up until the release of the Bear Family Box set in 2007. Richard Weize from Bear Family told me that when he was compiling that set EMI could locate neither the session tape nor the master recording of that song in their archives. A dub of the original 45 RPM single was used as the audio source. The differences between the two versions are quite evident. The album version times out at 2:23 and begins with George’s voice singing the first line of the first verse. The single version runs 2:38 and opens with the background singers performing the title line. The hit version is performed at a “shuffle” tempo.

    The best single CD compilation of George’s United Artists singles is a 1990 release on the Curb label, “George Jones Greatest Country Hits” (Curb D2-77369) The 11 tracks include all 8 of George’s top ten hits (including the LP version of “Not What I Had In Mind”) plus three more top 15 singles.

    Despite the much higher cost I heartily recommend the George Jones United Artists Bear Family Box set. The quality is consistent throughout all five discs and it truly serves as a monument to George’s talent. Trust me on this, you will NOT be disappointed if your budget can bear it.

    • pwdennis July 11, 2010 at 11:23 pm

      Amen to the UA Bear Box – it’ not the most essential of the Bear Boxes (the Webb Pierce set is) but it is among the very best in a long list of Bear boxed sets.

      The Curb disc is often overlooked simply because it is on Curb, but on this particular set Curb got it right

  3. Occasional Hope July 10, 2010 at 1:59 pm

    I really like the UA box set too – the quality is surprisingly high considering the high number of recordings George made over the period.

  4. Razor X July 10, 2010 at 8:25 pm

    The UA box set is my favorite of the three box sets of Jones’ music that Bear Family Records released. On the Musicor sets there are some examples of sloppiness as they rushed to complete some of those albums. That isn’t the case with the UA set.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: