My Kind of Country

Country music from a fan's point of view since 2008

Year In Review: Occasional Hope’s Top 10 singles of 2009

This has been the worst year for mainstream singles that I can remember. That was rubbed in for me when I started thinking about compiling not only this list but an upcoming list of the best singles of the decade. My shortlist comprised far more songs for every other year than for the current one. Not only that, but almost none of my picks for this year were actually hits. I didn’t deliberately pick obscure songs, and there have been some hits this year I have liked, but few that I have loved. It’s not just that radio seems to have moved in a direction I don’t care for, but also the labels have been picking as singles the songs I least liked from artists and albums I did like. But after a lot of thought, I’ve come up with this list of my personal favorites from 2009.

10. ‘Even Now’ – Caitlin & Will
This hardly even counts as a single, because the label pulled it before it had a chance to make an impact in favor of the over-produced ‘Address In the Stars’. That gamble didn’t pay off, and the duo was dropped by Columbia without an album release before the end of the year and have since split. However, this was a very impressive contemporary country duet with strong vocals, and it should have done much better.

9. ‘Cold Coffee And Hot Beer’ – John Anderson
The leadoff single from John Anderson’s Bigger Hands is a witty look at man so hopeless at life without his woman you can’t be really surprised she left. Sadly, it didn’t make any headway at radio.

8. ‘Stop The World (And Let Me Off)’ – Rhonda Vincent
My favorite track from bluegrass singer Rhonda Vincent’s current album, this cover of a real country classic was never going to get played on today’s country radio, but it’s a great song and recording regardless.

7. ‘Mama’ – Holly Williams
The daughter of Hank Williams Jr is more Americana than she is country, but this warm tribute to Holly’s mother following her parents’ divorce has a charm which cannot be denied – unless you’re a radio programmer.

6. ‘To Say Goodbye’ – Joey + Rory
I was disappointed that this moving song about the pain of loss and not being able to say goodbye was ignored by radio.

5. ‘She Never Got Me Over You’ – Mark Chesnutt
This lovely Keith Whitley/Dean Dillon/Hank Cochran song (never released by Whitley) was recorded by 90s star and current independent artist Mark Chesnutt on his most recent album (2008’s Rollin’ With The Flow), and it peaked on the Billboard singles chart at #49 earlier this year.

4. ‘Backwoods Barbie’ – Dolly Parton
Another non-charting single which deserved a wider audience, the title track of Dolly’s 2008 comeback attempt album is a remarkable song. Dolly’s image has often got in the way of a true appreciation of her as a singer and songwriter, and in this song she tackles that head-on.

3. ‘All I Ask For Anymore’ – Trace Adkins
Trace is a very frustrating artist for me. He has one of the best voices in country music, but too often he wastes his talent on material unworthy of it. Further, he and his label have been pioneers in the art of consistently picking his least good material as singles. So this song is a rare change – a genuine hit single from 2009 I actually like. The song is good if not great, and lifted by a beautifully judged vocal. I didn’t include the superb ‘Til The Last Shot’s Fired’ (nominated by Razor X last week) on my list, because I wanted to restrict it to formal singles, but if I had done, it would have challenged for the #1 spot.

2. ‘Busted‘ – Patty Loveless
Patty’s vibrant cover of the Harlan Howard-penned classic, which restored its original coal mining setting, is a true delight. It is the only single so far from her lovely Mountain Soul II. It was a top 10 hit for Johnny Cash in the 60s and for John Conlee in the 80s, and a crossover hit for Ray Charles in between, but Patty’s version, which easily rivals any of these, has failed to chart at all.

1. ‘High Cost Of Living’ – Jamey Johnson
I was disappointed by Jamey’s follow-up single, which sank without a trace, and surprised that the label didn’t try one of the other fine songs on That Lonesome Song, but this was far and away the best single of the year, with its serious, downbeat look at the cost of sin and addiction which was just too adult for the increasingly immature focus of country radio. It did manage to sneak into the top 40 earlier in the year.

Let’s hope next year is a bit better.

14 responses to “Year In Review: Occasional Hope’s Top 10 singles of 2009

  1. Steve from Boston December 14, 2009 at 9:38 am

    Another great list from MKOC, Thanks Lisa!

  2. Michael December 14, 2009 at 10:04 am

    Well done. The state of mainstream radio is definitely frustrating but you’ve managed to compile a nice list. I especially like your choice for number one. A great song.

  3. Lep December 14, 2009 at 11:52 am

    Wow, this list would almost be identical to mine.

    Great call on “High Cost of Living.” Easily one of the smartest, original, and strongest-written mainstream singles in recent memory in my opinion.

  4. Pingback: Garth Brooks Is Officially Unretired; Opry Planning Wednesday Night Show; Sunny Sweeney’s New Demo | The 9513

    • Leeann Ward December 14, 2009 at 7:44 pm

      Glad to see Holly Williams’ “Mama” on here. I think it’s an underrated song. It’s probably one of my favorites of the year, along with her dad’s “Red, White and Pink Slip Blues.”

      • J.R. Journey December 14, 2009 at 7:49 pm

        My favorite from that album was ‘Keep The Change’. I agree that both she and Hank Jr. made great albums this year.

        Also, great list. I especially like the Caitlin & Will song and the Jamey Johnson track is obviously excellent.

  5. KathyP December 14, 2009 at 8:10 pm

    Great call on “High Cost of Living.” Lyrics that will remain in country music history – “the high cost of livin ‘ain’t nothing like the cost of livin’ high.” Country though and through.

  6. Razor X December 14, 2009 at 9:13 pm

    Good list. It shows that there were some bright spots in country music this year after all, even though the good stuff was largely absent from the radio airwaves.

  7. Janelle December 18, 2009 at 11:58 pm

    I’m another big fan of that Jamey Johnson tune!! Even more so of his following single, “My Way to You”! I cannot believe country radio is letting such amazingly written and delivered songs fall to the wayside!! Very disappointing indeed!

  8. Janelle December 19, 2009 at 12:37 am

    Yeah, I guess thats true, Razor….I’ve been disillusioned and frustrated with country radio…but I had hopes of that one (My Way to You) making it thru the crap!

  9. Billie D Allen December 22, 2009 at 11:53 am

    PDF] Bridge

    Please check out this site. I would like to know what you think about the write up about the song on page five. Written by Rand Bishop and recorded by Emily Portman.

    Thanks, Be safe

  10. Pingback: Trace Adkins’ frustrating career and the prospects for change « My Kind Of Country

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: